Skip to main content

You may find yourself in a potential dispute over damage to, or non-performance of a building or structure.


From an engineering perspective, there are two ways to resolve such a dispute:

  • Expert Resolution, where an independent engineering expert is engaged by both parties to assess the damage or non-performance issue and recommend an appropriate remediation method, to be adopted by both parties. This method is highly recommended for the saving in time and cost to reach a resolution.
  • Expert Opinion is sought by each party of its own expert. Each Expert's opinion is then tested in Court before a Court determined resolution is handed down. This method is expensive in both time and cost.


In either case, you will need an engineer who is

  • an expert structural engineer
  • skilled in preparing expert opinions
  • and can suggest defensible technical alternatives which may reduce loss or improve benefit.


An Expert Opinion is formulated in response to questions from the Court.

The purpose of an expert opinion is to provide a bridge between primary evidence and a conclusion that cannot be reached without the application of expertise (Ref 1).
This bridge requires solid factual foundations, formulated from careful consideration of primary evidence and constructed using the in-depth knowledge and experience of the expert.


The expert's opinion report presents the case facts and the assumptions made from those facts ,  and a well reasoned conclusion.


(Ref 1) Dasreef Pty Ltd v Hawchar [2011] HCA 21, Heydon J.
Proof of assumption rule: For expert opinion to be admissible (under s 79 of the Evidence Act 1995 NSW), the expert must explicitly identify and prove the facts and assumptions on which their opinion is based.


Expert Engagements
CCP and COOEC v site Contractor [2009], Qingdao, China
Structural foundation failure.


Croft v QBCC [2025], QCAT 139, Oliver R.
Structural failure due to poor building practices.


Thompson v Awning Worx [2026], QCAT, Brown I.
Faulty construction, water penetration. 


Georgiou Building v West Steel Sheds WA P/L [2017], WA Supreme Court CIV2870
Challenge to engineering design consultant


Incitec Pivot, 2024
Building collapse


Veolia, Expert Determination,2025
Extensive fire damage to process building